Watch the video to respond
October 2026
In this survey, you are being invited to contribute your opinions about training needs for people who are peer-reviewing journal manuscripts in the field of toxicology and environmental health.
You are eligible to respond if you are an adult with an interest in toxicology or environmental health research in any capacity. This includes lab studies, epidemiology, in vivo or in vitro methods, risk assessment or risk management, evidence review, or any role in which you may support, conduct, or use toxicological or environmental health research. You do not need to have any previous experience with peer review.
This survey is being conducted by the Institute for Evidence-Based Toxicology gGmbH (IEBT, www.iebt.eu), a non-profit research organisation based in Germany, to provide data on the toxicology community's experience of conducting peer review.
The results of this survey will be published as a preprint and submitted to the journal Evidence-Based Toxicology, to support organisations that are planning activities to improve toxicologists’ capacity and confidence in peer review.
One such activity is “PeerCore”, a programme of online training activities being organised by the Evidence-Based Toxicology Collaboration (EBTC, www.ebtox.org), scheduled to run from late October 2026 through to January 2027.
If you are interested in hearing more about PeerCore or participating in the training activities, at the end of this survey you will be given a link to a separate sign-up form for the EBTC mailing list for PeerCore.
How this survey works
In the next pages, we will ask you about:
> Your work area (5 questions)
> Your experience peer reviewing manuscripts (5 questions)
> Your training needs in relation to peer review (4 questions)
> Your approach to peer review (7 questions)
Completing this survey will take about 15 minutes. You may skip questions you do not want to answer, and you may stop responding at any time. Please note, the responses you submit before you stop will still be recorded and used.
Your participation is voluntary, and you will not be compensated for your time. You will not directly benefit from your participation in the survey, though you may find it interesting. The findings will help organisations plan training programs intended to benefit the scientific community (including you, if you participate).
Anonymity
This survey is anonymous. We will not collect any identifying information about you, including your IP address. We have designed the survey so that identifying characteristics cannot be reverse-engineered from your answers to any questions. If you inadvertently include potentially identifying information in a free-text response, we will remove it from stored data.
We are using the GDPR-compliant survey platform Youform to run the survey. We will store survey data in YouForm while the survey is open online. When we close the survey, we will export the results to IEBT’s secure SharePoint servers and delete the data from YouForm. Once the survey results have been published as a preprint, we will delete the data from IEBT’s servers.
Ethics approval
This research involves generating new data about participants’ experiences around peer-review. Per IEBT research policies, it has been deemed by IEBT staff that the research does not need to be submitted for ethical approval.
This is because participation in the research is (a) anonymous, (b) the participants are fully aware of the goals and conditions of the research, (c) the research does not involve intervening in the physical integrity of the participants or exposure to exceptionally strong stimuli, nor (d) involves a risk of causing mental harm that exceeds the limits of normal daily life to participants or their family members or others close to them, nor (e) involves any potential threat to the safety of participants or researchers or their family members or others close to them.
Consent
By proceeding with this survey, you indicate that you have read this information, you voluntarily agree to participate, and you give consent for us to use your responses for the purposes described above.
Watch the video to respond
'Oops! something went wrong.',
Check as many responses as apply.
Check as many responses as apply.
Check as many responses as apply.
Check as many responses as apply.
Enter as many countries as is relevant.
Watch the video to respond
'Oops! something went wrong.',
Here we are asking about peer-review of manuscripts submitted for publication in a scientific journal. Peer-review of other documents, such as grants, contests or awards, funding proposals, is not of interest here.
Choose the option that best fits your situation.
Choose the option that best fits your situation.
On a scale of 1-6, select the option that best fits your situation.
(0) means not at all confident; (6) means extremely confident.
If you have not yet learned, mark "never" for all.
| Never | Once | More than once | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
I taught myself (self-study) |
|||
|
I received training in a webinar |
|||
|
I completed a structured course |
|||
|
I received guidance from a colleague |
|||
|
I had a mentor for peer review |
|||
Post-publication peer-review happens after a manuscript has been published, as opposed to more traditional models where peer-reviewers help determine whether a manuscript should be published.
PubPeer is an example of a post-publication peer-review platform. After the article is published by a journal, readers can use these platforms to publish comments about a manuscript.
Select the option that best fits your situation.
Watch the video to respond
'Oops! something went wrong.',
Indicate which of the following are low, moderate, or high priority for you, in terms of what you would be most likely to engage with.
| Low | Moderate | High | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Written materials |
|||
|
Lectures without Q&A |
|||
|
Interactive Q&A sessions |
|||
|
Debates between experts |
|||
|
Working alone |
|||
|
Working in groups |
|||
|
Practical, hands-on exercises |
|||
|
Home assignments |
|||
For each of the below, select the option that best fits
| Low | Moderate | High | Don't Know | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Confidence-building |
||||
|
How journals handle manuscripts |
||||
|
How best to help authors |
||||
|
How best to help editors |
||||
|
Different models of peer-review |
||||
|
How being a peer reviewer can be good for me |
||||
|
What's the role of peer review |
||||
|
When to accept invitations to peer review |
||||
|
Collective reviews ("journal clubs") of published papers |
||||
|
Mentoring for peer review |
||||
|
Co-authoring a peer review |
||||
|
Post-publication peer review (in platforms like F1000 or PubPeer) |
||||
Use the slider to tell us how long you would like a typical session to be, in minutes.
Use the slider to indicate how many sessions of training you would like to have.
Watch the video to respond
'Oops! something went wrong.',
Please complete the statement in the way that best fits your approach
Please complete the statement in the way that best fits your approach
An appraisal tool can be a questionnaire, form, or checklist that you choose yourself or which has been provided by the journal.
Select the option that best fits your situation.
Select the option that best fits your situation.
Select all that apply.
Select the option that best fits your situation.
Watch the video to respond
'Oops! something went wrong.',
Thank you!
If you would like to find out more about EBTC's PeerCore program, for building confidence and skills in peer-review, click the button below.
The button links to the EBTC website.